求解P1方程的变分节块方法

Variational Nodal Method for Solving P1 Equation

  • 摘要: 从中子输运方程出发,先经过P1近似获得P1方程,再经过扩散近似即可获得中子扩散方程。与扩散方程相比,P1方程直接保留了完整的1阶各向异性散射,消除了扩散近似。为了求解该方程,本文参照各向异性散射的变分节块方法,推导了2阶奇偶型P1方程,然后构建了求解P1方程的变分节块法理论模型,包括泛函构造、Ritz离散和变分推导,获得了离散后的P1方程。开发了NECP-VioletP1程序,通过与P1方程的有限差分求解程序的定量对比进行了验证与分析。结果表明,该程序计算的有效增殖因数与加密网格的有限差分程序的最大偏差为−12 pcm,裂变率分布的最大相对偏差为−0.76%,充分证明了该程序的准确性,为开展基于P1理论的堆芯物理分析提供了核心求解器。

     

    Abstract: Starting from the neutron transport equation, the diffusion equation is firstly derived via the P1 approximation, and subsequently the neutron diffusion equation is obtained through the diffusion approximation. Compared with the diffusion equation, the P1 equation directly retains the complete first-order anisotropic scattering and eliminates the diffusion approximation. Existing research indicates that for cases involving strong anisotropic scattering, the computational accuracy achieved using the P1 equation is significantly higher than that obtained with the diffusion equation, without significantly increasing computation time. Therefore, to accurately solve this equation within the coarse-mesh nodal method framework, this paper referred to the variational nodal method for anisotropic scattering PN equation, to derive the second-order even-parity form of the steady-state multigroup P1 equation. Then, a theoretical model of the variational nodal method for solving the P1 equation was constructed, which included functional formulation based on the Galerkin variational principle, Ritz discretization using three-dimensional orthogonal basis functions for the flux within nodes and for the current on surfaces, and variational derivation to yield the spatially discretized P1 equation. Furthermore, based on an existing variational nodal method code for the diffusion equation, a variational nodal code for the P1 equation, named NECP-VioletP1, was developed. The modifications included enhancing the cross-section input module to handle first-order scattering matrices, implementing new routines to calculate specific response matrices, and integrating the first-order scattering source term into the iterative solution scheme. And its’ verification and analysis were conducted through quantitative comparison with the finite difference code for solving the P1 equation, set up for several benchmark cases including 2D single-assembly with different fuel enrichments and poison rod configurations, 2×2 assemblies with increasing heterogeneity, and 2D mini-core problem with a light water reflector. The results show that the maximum deviation of the effective multiplication factor (keff) calculated by this code from that of the finite difference code with refined-mesh is −12 pcm, and the maximum relative deviation of the fission rate distribution is −0.76%, with the largest errors predictably occurring at high-gradient regions like fuel-reflector interfaces. A comparative analysis on the mini-core problem highlights the significant advantage of the P1 method over the diffusion method. Furthermore, spatial convergence studies indicate that a 5th-order flux expansion and 2nd-order current expansion within the variational nodal method achieve sufficient accuracy with computational efficiency superior to mesh refinement in the finite difference method (FDM). This study successfully establishes a robust and accurate variational nodal method for solving the P1 equation. The developed NECP-VioletP1 code proves to be a highly effective solver, offering a superior accuracy compared to traditional diffusion theory. It provides a reliable core solver for advanced, high-fidelity core physics analysis based on the P1 theory.

     

/

返回文章
返回